The Urban Fortress: Disconnect from Nature

You’ve named something profoundly sad: the question “have you ever seen wildlife?” should be absurd—and yet it’s not.

For most of human history, that question would have been incomprehensible. Like asking “have you ever breathed air?” or “have you ever seen the sky?” Of course you’ve seen wildlife. You lived among it, with it, sometimes terrified of it, sometimes dependent on it, always aware of it.

But now? Millions of people—perhaps billions—live their entire lives in ecological fortresses. Concrete and glass barriers between them and everything that isn’t human or domesticated. The only animals they encounter are pets, pests, and pigeons. The only plants they see are in pots or intentionally planted in precise rows.

We’ve become the first humans in history who have to seek out nature as a recreational activity rather than simply existing within it.

The Fortress City

You’re right to call cities fortresses. That’s exactly what they are:

Designed to keep nature out.

We’ve spent centuries engineering our environments to exclude the wild:

• Pesticides to kill the insects
• Concrete to cover the soil
• Glass towers that birds die crashing into
• Noise that drowns out birdsong
• Light pollution that erases the stars
• Air that’s been filtered, conditioned, controlled
• Water that only flows where we’ve directed it

The goal was mastery over nature. We succeeded. And in succeeding, we’ve exiled ourselves from the world we evolved in.

A child can grow up in a major city and never:

• See a wild mammal larger than a rat
• Touch soil that hasn’t been treated
• Experience true darkness
• Hear silence
• See the Milky Way
• Watch a bird build a nest
• Witness a predator hunting
• Feel genuinely uncertain about whether they’re safe from animals

This seems like victory—we’re safe, comfortable, climate-controlled. But it’s also sensory deprivation on a species-wide scale.

What Our Ancestors Knew

Your ancestors—everyone’s ancestors—lived in constant relationship with wildlife.

Not romantic relationship. Often terrifying relationship. They:

• Tracked animals to eat them
• Avoided animals that would eat them
• Competed with animals for resources
• Observed animal behavior to predict weather, seasons, danger
• Knew hundreds of species by sight, sound, track, scat
• Understood migration patterns, breeding cycles, territorial boundaries
• Could read the forest/savanna/tundra like you read street signs

They were ecologically literate in ways modern humans cannot comprehend. A child in a hunter-gatherer society knew more about the living world at age ten than most PhD biologists know about their own local ecosystem today.

This wasn’t hobby knowledge—it was survival. You had to know which plants were edible, which were poison. Which mushrooms would feed you, which would kill you. Which animal tracks meant run, which meant food, which meant nothing.

Nature wasn’t “out there”—it was everywhere, always, impossible to ignore.

And that constant presence shaped human consciousness. Our stories, our gods, our understanding of time and cycles, our metaphors, our dreams—all emerged from living embedded in the natural world.

The Cost of the Fortress

What have we lost by building these walls?

1. Ecological Understanding

Most urban people have no idea:

• Where their water comes from
• Where their waste goes
• What grows naturally in their region
• What animals live within miles of them
• What’s edible in a park
• How ecosystems function
• That the insects they’re killing are keeping them alive

They live on a planet they don’t understand, in an ecosystem they can’t read, utterly dependent on systems they’re blind to.

This ignorance has consequences. How can you protect what you’ve never seen? How can you mourn the extinction of species you didn’t know existed? How can you understand climate change when you’ve never experienced a natural seasonal cycle unmediated by heating and air conditioning?

You can’t love what you don’t know. And you don’t fight to save what you don’t love.

2. Sensory Impoverishment

Humans evolved with:

• Variable temperatures
• Natural light rhythms
• Diverse smells (earth, rain, animals, plants, decay)
• Complex soundscapes (wind, water, animal calls, rustling)
• Physical challenge (uneven terrain, weather, distance)
• Darkness
• Silence
• Stars

Modern urban life offers:

• Climate control (constant 70°F)
• Artificial light (constant brightness, disrupted circadian rhythms)
• Limited smells (exhaust, food, cleaning products)
• Constant noise (traffic, construction, machinery)
• Flat surfaces (sidewalks, floors, roads)
• Light pollution (never truly dark)
• Noise pollution (never truly quiet)
• No stars

We live in sensory monotony. The same sounds, smells, textures, temperatures, day after day. Our nervous systems evolved for ecological diversity and instead get industrial homogeneity.

Some researchers believe this contributes to:

• Increased anxiety and depression
• Attention disorders
• Disconnection and alienation
• Reduced stress resilience
• Spiritual emptiness

We’re animals kept in captivity, and we’re showing symptoms of it.

3. The Loss of Scale

In the city, you are the largest thing.

Humans dominate. Everything else—the trees, the birds, the insects—are smaller, fewer, diminished. You never feel genuinely small in the presence of something vast and wild.

But in wilderness:

• A bear makes you realize your fragility
• A mountain makes you realize your brevity
• The ocean makes you realize your insignificance
• The forest makes you realize your interdependence
• The night sky makes you realize your cosmic smallness

This is psychologically essential. Humans need to feel small sometimes. To recognize we’re not the center of everything. To experience awe that comes from encountering something vast, ancient, indifferent to our existence.

Without wilderness, we lose proper perspective. We start to believe the world exists for us, can be controlled by us, bends to our will. We forget we’re animals on a planet we share.

4. Alienation From Our Own Nature

We are mammals. Primates. Animals.

But in the fortress city, it’s easy to forget. We’re:

• Climate-controlled (never too hot or cold)
• Well-fed (never truly hungry)
• Safe from predators (never hunted)
• Separated from death (animals killed far away, bodies hidden)
• Disconnected from our bodies (sitting all day, rarely using full physical capacity)

We experience ourselves as minds driving meat vehicles, rather than animals who think.

And this creates profound alienation. We don’t understand our own:

• Instincts (why we’re afraid of certain things)
• Emotions (why we feel seasonal changes in mood)
• Physical needs (why we crave movement, sun, touch)
• Mortality (we’ve medicalized death so thoroughly that dying seems like a failure rather than nature)

Reconnecting with wildlife—even briefly—reminds us: We are also wild. We are also nature. We are also temporary, mortal, part of the cycle.

The Irony: Nature Persists Anyway

Here’s what’s strange: Even in the fortress, nature finds cracks.

Cities aren’t actually devoid of wildlife—we just don’t notice it:

The urban ecosystem includes:

• Rats, mice, squirrels navigating infrastructure
• Pigeons, crows, seagulls adapted to human food
• Insects everywhere (though declining catastrophically)
• Trees (street trees, park trees, struggling but alive)
• Soil organisms beneath the concrete
• Foxes, raccoons, coyotes in many cities
• Hawks hunting pigeons on skyscrapers
• Peregrine falcons nesting on buildings
• Plants cracking through sidewalks

Nature is resilient. It doesn’t accept the fortress.

But we’ve trained ourselves not to see this. The pigeon is dismissed as “sky rat.” The weed breaking through concrete is “something to spray.” The mouse in the wall is pest, not wildlife.

We’ve created a mental category—”wildlife”—that means “animals somewhere else.” Animals here are pests, nuisances, invaders. As if the city belongs to us and nature is trespassing.

But the truth is: we built on their land. They were here first. They’re the natives; we’re the invasive species.

What Happens to Children of the Fortress

This disconnection is especially tragic for children.

Previous human generations learned about the world through direct experience:

• Climbing trees
• Catching insects
• Following animal tracks
• Swimming in rivers
• Getting lost in woods
• Building shelters
• Making fires
• Observing weather

They developed:

• Physical competence and confidence
• Risk assessment skills
• Ecological knowledge
• Patience (watching animals requires stillness)
• Awe and wonder
• Respect for forces larger than themselves

Now, children learn about nature through:

• Screens (nature documentaries)
• Books (pictures of animals)
• Zoos (imprisoned animals in artificial habitats)
• Highly supervised “nature experiences”

They’re told nature is:

• Dangerous (don’t touch anything)
• Fragile (stay on the path)
• Separate (it’s “out there,” not here)
• Managed (parks, preserves, sanctioned spaces)

This creates a generation that loves the idea of nature without experiencing nature.

They’ll say they care about the environment while having no embodied understanding of what that means. They’ll watch documentaries about rainforests while never having climbed a tree. They’ll mourn polar bears they’ll never see while ignoring the birds outside their window.

Abstract concern without visceral connection.

The Question That Shouldn’t Need Asking

So yes—the question “have you ever seen wildlife?” is absurd.

But it’s absurdly necessary.

Because the honest answer for many people is:

“I’ve seen animals in zoos. I’ve seen squirrels in parks. I’ve seen birds. Does that count? I’ve never seen a wild animal in actual wilderness, in its own territory, living completely independent of humans. I’ve never been in a place where I was the visitor and they were home.”

And that answer reveals: We’ve created a world where experiencing the wild requires money, time, transportation, and deliberate effort.

Nature has become a consumer experience—something you buy access to, something you travel to see, something packaged and sold as “ecotourism.”

Our ancestors would find this incomprehensible.

“You have to pay to see a forest? You have to schedule time to experience wildlife? You have to travel to see animals? What are you doing the rest of the time? Where are you living that has no animals?”

The fortress. We’re living in the fortress.

What We’re Doing About It (And Whether It’s Enough)

Some are trying to break the fortress:

Urban rewilding:

• Green roofs and walls
• Wildlife corridors
• Native plant gardens
• Bee hotels and bat boxes
• Removing concrete to restore soil

Education programs:

• Teaching children about local ecosystems
• Citizen science projects
• Nature deficit disorder awareness
• Forest schools

Personal reconnection:

• Hiking, camping, backpacking
• Birdwatching
• Gardening
• Foraging

But here’s the question: Is visiting nature enough?

If you live in the fortress 360 days a year and spend 5 days “in nature,” have you reconnected? Or have you just consumed nature as entertainment while remaining fundamentally alienated from it?

True connection isn’t tourism. It’s daily relationship.

It’s:

• Knowing what phase the moon is in without looking it up
• Noticing when migrating birds arrive and leave
• Recognizing the trees on your street
• Tracking the seasons by what’s blooming
• Listening to the soundscape around you
• Watching the same patch of ground change through the year

This is possible even in cities—but it requires choosing to pay attention to what the fortress wants you to ignore.

The Philosophical Problem

The fortress raises a question:

Are we still the same species we were when we lived embedded in nature?

Our bodies are the same. Our DNA is essentially unchanged. But our lived experience is so radically different that we might be psychologically, spiritually, culturally different creatures.

A human who:

• Has never experienced genuine darkness
• Has never been cold enough to fear for survival
• Has never been hungry beyond mild discomfort
• Has never encountered a wild predator
• Has never navigated by stars
• Has never seen the Milky Way
• Has never experienced silence
• Has never witnessed death that wasn’t human

Is that still a human in the way our ancestors were human?

Or are we something new—post-natural humans—living in a post-natural world, with all the psychological and spiritual costs that entails?

What You’re Really Asking

When you point out that cities have become fortresses preventing people from seeing wildlife, you’re naming a profound impoverishment.

Not material impoverishment—most city dwellers are materially wealthier than their rural ancestors.

But spiritual, sensory, ecological impoverishment.

We’ve traded:

• Direct experience for mediated information
• Participation in ecosystems for consumption of resources
• Embeddedness in nature for separation from nature
• Wildness for comfort
• Freedom for security
• The real for the controlled

And most people don’t even realize what was lost, because you can’t miss what you never knew existed.

---

The saddest part isn’t that people have to answer “no” when asked if they’ve seen wildlife. The saddest part is that many don’t understand why that’s a tragedy.

They think nature is a nice bonus, a weekend recreation, a pleasant luxury. They don’t understand it’s where we came from, what we’re made of, what keeps us psychologically and spiritually whole.

The fortress protects us from danger. But it also imprisons us in an artificial world that slowly starves us of something essential we can’t name but desperately need.

What do you think happens to a species that completely severs itself from the ecosystem that shaped it for millions of years? Are we finding out?